NYC Rental Market Update September 2026

Here’s a quick snapshot of the NYC rental market for September 2026, with a focus on Manhattan and Brooklyn. You can view stats from the previous month here. 

Infographic showing the rental stats of the NYC rental market for the month of September 2026

Summary

There was no relief in sight for Manhattan renters as rents hit another record high in September. 

The increase in prices – up 9% compared to last year – was likely spurred by tight inventory, which has continued to decline. Listings were down a whopping 16% compared to September 2025.

Not surprisingly, high prices and fewer listings created a chilling effect for leasing activity. Signed leases were down by 19% compared to August and down by 5% compared to the prior year. This was one of the slowest Septembers for leasing in the last 8 years.  

Despite a very sharp decline in listings (down 25% compared to last year), Brooklyn saw very good leasing activity. In fact, with lease signings up 10% compared to 2025, it was one of the strongest Septembers since 2020. 

So why did Brooklyn do so much better than Manhattan? Prices. Even though prices increased on an annual basis, they did so much more modestly compared to Manhattan (up just 5%). 

What’s Next?

October may finally bring some (very slight) relief to Manhattan renters. But not necessarily in the form of prices or inventory. The latter is likely to continue to decline which is typical of seasonality once fall hits. 

Instead, relief is likely to come in the form of less competition from other renters. But high interest rates could upend that if more potential buyers stay in the rental market. 

Brooklyn is likely to see more of the same – strong leasing performance with modest price increases. But renters may likewise see a bit of relief as well if competition cools off with the change in seasons. 

As always, preparation is a must. Here’s a video reminder of what you need in order to put your best foot forward  – NYC Apartment Hunting Tips – The Key to Getting An Application in FAST. 

To get the full NYC Rental Market Update for September 2026, click here. 

And if you’re thinking about getting a new rental in NYC, then check out my Renter Resources page and get my FREE guide to renting in NYC when you join my email 

Categories

Archives

Sign up for my newsletter

Get my NYC First Time Home Buyer Guide FREE when you sign up for my monthly newsletter

Subscription Form

By clicking Sign Up you're confirming that you agree with our Terms and Conditions.

Related Posts

How Much Does It Cost to Own a 3 Bedroom in NYC? (November 2026)

Read more

NYC Real Estate Market Update Q3 2026 – Manhattan & Brooklyn

Read more

September 2026 Sales Market Update

Read more

How Much Does It Cost to Own a 2 Bedroom in NYC? (Oct 2026)

Read more

Aug 2026 Sales Market Update

Read more

NYC Rental Market Update August 2026

Read more

How Much Does It Cost to Own a 1 Bedroom in NYC? (Sept 2026)

Read more

NYC Rental Market Update July 2026

Read more